|Year : 2009 | Volume
| Issue : 3 | Page : 206-211
Sexual practice and perception of HIV/AIDS amongst men who have sex with men in Kolkata
Soumya Deb1, Sinjita Dutta2, Aparajita Dasgupta2, Biswajit Biswas1
1 Department of Community Medicine, IPGMER, SSKM Hospital, Kolkata, India
2 Department of Preventive and Social Medicine (PSM), All India Institute of Hygiene and Public Health, 110, C.R.Avenue, Kolkata - 700 073, India
|Date of Submission||11-Aug-2008|
|Date of Acceptance||28-Dec-2008|
|Date of Web Publication||29-Aug-2009|
W2C(R), Flat-3/5, Phase-IVB, Golf Green, Kolkata-700 095, West Bengal
Source of Support: None, Conflict of Interest: None
| Abstract|| |
Background and Objectives: Men who have Sex with Men (MSM) are a vulnerable population and need special attention in the fight against the global pandemic of HIV/AIDS. A study was conducted in an MSM clinic to find out to their varied socio-demographic characteristics, their knowledge and attitude towards HIV/AIDS, and its association with their different sexual practices. Materials and Methods: Descriptive, cross sectional study conducted in an MSM clinic in central Kolkata. Results: A total of 108 MSM were studied over a period of six months. A majority (25%) were students, followed by drivers (22.2%), with mean age being 22.8 years. About 13.9% of them were illiterate and 30.6% of them married. A majority (75%) of the clients were initiated to first sexual act during adolescence. Most (44%) of them had indulged in sexual acts with two/three partners in the past one month. The most common form of sexual act was receptive anal sex (83.3%). The commonest reasons for indulging into such sexual acts with men were increased pleasure to have sex with men and increased sexual urge (38.9% and 27.8%) while 19.4% performed such acts in an intoxicated state. Only 22.2% ever used condom in the last one month during sexual acts. Their knowledge and positive attitude towards HIV/AIDS increased significantly with increase in literacy status ( P less than 0.01). Only 36 (33.3%) knew about HIV transmission through anal route while only 35.2% knew the correct method to use condom. Favorable sexual practices like using a condom or having fewer partners was more among the literates than the illiterates ( P less than 0.05). Alarmingly 44.4% felt that one should have sex without a condom if his sex partner was extremely attractive, 88.9% felt that using a condom was not necessary if his partner was clean and hygienic, 69.4% felt that anal sex is for fun, so no condom is required while 43.5% felt getting HIV was a matter of bad luck. Conclusion: Proper IEC to promote condom use and promotion of safe sexual practice among MSM is the need of the hour.
Keywords: Anal sex, HIV, MSM, sex partner, sexual practice
|How to cite this article:|
Deb S, Dutta S, Dasgupta A, Biswas B. Sexual practice and perception of HIV/AIDS amongst men who have sex with men in Kolkata. Indian J Community Med 2009;34:206-11
|How to cite this URL:|
Deb S, Dutta S, Dasgupta A, Biswas B. Sexual practice and perception of HIV/AIDS amongst men who have sex with men in Kolkata. Indian J Community Med [serial online] 2009 [cited 2020 Dec 2];34:206-11. Available from: https://www.ijcm.org.in/text.asp?2009/34/3/206/55285
| Introduction|| |
Next to South Africa and Nigeria, India has the third largest number of persons living with HIV/AIDS in the world. According to the data on the National AIDS Control Organization, adult HIV prevalence in India is approximately 0.36 percent, amounting to between two and 3.1 million people. It is also estimated that 85% of HIV transmission is sexual. Though the prevalence of HIV/AIDS among MSM in India was officially set at 5.69% percent in 2006, it is felt by the researchers that this figure underestimates the impact of unsafe sexual practice of the MSM on the epidemic of HIV/AIDS in India, especially since global estimates suggest that five per cent to 10 per cent of HIV prevalence is attributable to sexual transmission between men. Truck drivers are a group known to have higher levels of homosexual behavior than the general public. Therefore, the high rates of HIV infection among truck drivers may be an indicator of the importance of homosexual transmission in the India epidemic because homosexual behavior also takes place outside of this particular group.
The reliability of HIV infection data among Men Who Have sex with Men (MSM) is influenced by: (i) the lack of knowledge and understanding of MSM behavioral patterns as many MSM do not have a conscious sexual identity/orientation; the fact that (ii) many do not consider reporting on their same sex behaviors even when asked; (iii) many do not identify their sexual behavior as MSM since their partners are not perceived as men; (iv) many gay-identified men as well as others who have developed a sexual identity, are reluctant to identify themselves and disclose their same-sex behaviors or sexual orientation to health care providers, fearing stigma, discrimination and exclusion.
The framework of male to male sex is substantially divergent and inclusive. 'Men who have sex with men (MSM)' denotes men who have sex with other men regardless of the presence or absence of any specific sexual identity. It includes normative males who desire to penetrate as the only signifier, feminized males (kothis) who desire to be penetrated by other males, hijras who are born as biological or anatomical males but reject their masculine identity in due course of time to identify, either as women or not-men, or in between man and woman, or neither man or woman (almost like Kothis) and adolescent and other males who desire to experiment for fun. Males are often easier to access for sex than females, while male sex workers are usually cheaper than female sex workers are. MSM includes self-identified gay men, primarily among the urban, English speaking elite and middle classes. Without a welfare system, and with significant levels of unemployment or low level incomes, male sex work can be a way out in terms of supporting the self and family. This is not to imply that males involved in sex work do not enjoy the sex with other males. Often they may also have a regular male partner, and/or a wife or girlfriend. Thus, the MSM is a very high risk group and acts as a bridge in transmission of sexually transmitted disease to the general population.
There is definitely an insensitive attitude towards this population leading to their social exclusion and deprivation of service provision, treatment and care. Again, an underestimate of the number of at-risk MSM in any given population apparently leads to lack of resources to support HIV intervention programs exclusively for this vulnerable population. No doubt these people live in a world of their own with misconceptions and wrong notions regarding sexually transmitted diseases especially HIV/AIDS with little access to health education regarding these issues.
With this in the backdrop, the present study was conducted in an MSM clinic in Central Kolkata. The clinic is run under the auspices of an NGO, Manas Bangla, which provides care and treatment to the MSM in eastern India especially West Bengal.
| Materials and Methods|| |
A descriptive, cross sectional study was conducted among MSM attending a MSM clinic in Central Kolkata. The clinic is located in Kadapara area of Central Kolkata and is frequented by MSM and other male clients as well. The clinic runs on Mondays, Wednesdays and Fridays of every week. The objectives of the study were as follows:
The different variables under study included socio-demographic characteristics like age, literacy status, occupation, length of stay, living arrangement, marital status and per capita monthly income (PCI); different aspects of knowledge regarding HIV/AIDS like ever heard about the disease, its varied modes of transmission (checklist given), seriousness of problem, curability of the disease, heard of condom and knowing correct use of condom. Scoring regarding their knowledge was decided as follows - yes +1, no -1, except for the last question i.e. knowing the method of using condom where Correct knowledge was assigned+1, incorrect -1, Do Not Know (DNK) 0, (thus maximum possible score was plus15 and minimum score attainable was minus 12).
- To find out the different socio-demographic characteristics of the study population
- To elicit the their perception of HIV/AIDS
- To find out their pattern of sexual practice
- To find out the association, if any, of the knowledge and attitude of the study population with their literacy status and sexual practices
Besides, the following enquiries were made to find out the attitude of the study population-
Correct attitude (+1), Incorrect attitude (-1), DNK 0, (Max score +18, Minimum Score - 18)
- If the man is sterilized, there is no need to wear condom
- Condoms are only for family planning purposes
- It is not necessary to use condom with male sex partner
- I may decide to have sex without a condom if my sex partner is extremely attractive
- If my partner is extremely clean and hygienic, then using a condom is not necessary
- One cannot have proper sex while using a condom
- Anal sex is just for fun, so no condom is required
- If both partners have HIV, there is no need to use condoms
- Condoms can cause premature ejaculation
- Whether or not we use a condom during anal sex is up to my male partner
- My partner and I will use a condom if I tell him we should
- My partner encourages me to use condoms
- I encourage my partner to use condoms
- HIV only affects poor people
- Getting HIV is a matter of bad luck
- If a person has HIV/AIDS, his family relationships will be destroyed
- If a person has HIV/AIDS, his relationship with friends will be destroyed
- If a person has HIV/AIDS, his respect in the society will be destroyed
The varied sexual practices of the study population was also elicited by enquiring about their first sexual partner, age of first sex, ever used condom, use of condom during last sexual act, types of sexual acts practiced in last 12 months, types of sexual partners in the last 12 months, number of partners over the last one month and reasons for choosing a male partner for sexual act.
All MSM clients visiting the STD clinic during the study period of six months during 2007 were interviewed using a pre-designed semistructured questionnaire. The questions were taken from a research questionnaire approved by State AIDS Control Society of West Bengal. All the clients were interviewed after taking informed oral consent and on the basis of anonymity. A total of 108 MSMs visited the clinic with varied symptoms of sexually transmitted diseases like urethral discharge, perianal and penile warts, dysuria, ulcer on the glans, anal discharge as well as general complaints like fever, cough and cold and generalized body ache during the study period. These symptoms were treated as per syndromic approach in the clinic and referrals were made to the nearest medical college and hospital wherever felt necessary. All the attendees who visited the clinic during the study period willingly consented to the study. The results were analyzed at the end of the study using suitable statistical tests taking help of Microsoft Office Excel 2003 and EpiInfo version 3.2 softwares.
| Results and Discussion|| |
[Table 1] shows the socio-demographic characteristics of the study population. The mean age of the study population was only 22.1 years, most of them being in the age group 19 to 23 years. The literacy status was varied with 13.9% being illiterate while 16.7% were educated up to higher secondary and above. Many of the MSM (22.2%) had migrated from neighboring states of Jharkhand, Bihar, Orissa and UP and were staying in the locality for less than two years. The study population belonged to various occupations -unemployed, drivers, businessmen or professionals. However, what was extremely alarming was a majority (25%) of clients were students. Some students indulged in such practices while residing in mess and hostels. Almost one-third of the MSM were married. Besides, the per capita monthly income (PCI) was also found to be quite varied with 8.3% having a PCI of more than Rs 2500 while 25% had a monthly PCI of less than Rs 500.
[Table 2] depicts the pattern of sexual practice of the study population. The age of first sexual act was found to be as low as 10 years in two instances. It was also observed that majority (44.2 %) had their first sexual act in the age group 15-19 years and the mean age of first such act only 16.6 years. As expected, the first sexual partner was a male friend in majority of the cases (50.9%) but it was also observed that CSW, girlfriends, classmates, relatives and even spouse at times was the partner in their first sexual act. The study population mostly had multiple partners with 58.2% having more than one partner in the last one month. Even in 5.6% of the cases, the number of partners in the last one month was alarmingly high in the order of six or more. Another interesting finding was the presence of male sex workers as sexual partners in 16 instances in the last one year or so. The most common sexual act was receptive anal sex followed by vaginal sex, oral sex and insertive anal sex. The use of condom was very poor with only 15.7% using the barrier method during vaginal intercourse and 6.5% during anal intercourse in the last one month. Among the study participants, only 22% had ever attended VCCTC and undergone the HIV test, only one of them was HIV positive. The HIV positive person was incidentally suffering from perianal carcinoma. It was found that majority i.e. 80 (74%) of the MSM who visited the clinic were feminized males practicing receptive anal sex (traditionally called Kothis) followed by Pariks (15, 14%) who considered themselves real males and practiced insertive anal sex, Duplis (8, 7%) who practiced both insertive and receptive form of sex and Eunuchs (five, five per cent) or the transsexuals traditionally called Hijras.
[Table 3] shows the association of knowledge score of the study population with factors like literacy status, condom use and number of partners in the last one month. Overall knowledge score of the study population was poor with 47.2% scoring less than three out of a maximum possible score of 15. Knowledge score significantly increased with the literacy status of the study population (P less than 0.05). The practice of ever using condoms in the last one month was significantly more (P less than 0.05) in men with higher knowledge score. There was however inverse relation between knowledge regarding HIV/AIDS and number of sex partners (P less than 0.01). Although all the MSM attending the clinic had heard about HIV/AIDS, only 36 of them (33.3%) knew about transmission through anal route while majority i.e. 61 (56.5%) knew about transmission through vaginal intercourse. Only 38 MSM (35.2%) knew the correct use of condom.
[Table 4] depicts the attitude score of the study population and its association with the same factors (namely literacy status, condom use and number of partners in the last one month). Like knowledge, attitude score significantly increased with literacy status of the study population (P less than 0.05). The favorable practice of ever using condom in the last one month was significantly more among men with higher attitude scores. Some alarming findings included 48 (44.4%) felt that they will perform sexual act without a condom if their sexual partner is extremely attractive, 96 (88.9%) felt that using a condom is not necessary if the partner is clean and hygienic, 75 (69.4%) felt that anal sex is for fun, so no condom is required, 47 (43.5%) felt getting HIV was a matter of bad luck, 57 (52.8%) felt their respect in the society would be destroyed if they had HIV/AIDS while only 35 (32.4%) encouraged their partners to use condoms.
[Table 5] shows the varied responses given by the study population when asked about the reason of such sexual acts performed by MSM. Interestingly majority (40%) of the study population had sex with men for pleasure, 28% felt it was because of increased sexual urge while 22% thought they couldn't resist their sexual urge. Another striking finding was that, 8.3% were forced into the act while 1.9% performed such acts for exchange of money. About 19% of the men did the act in an intoxicated state.
| Conclusion and Recommendations|| |
The MSM attending the clinic came from diverse walks of life ranging from unemployed unskilled workers to professionals and students. The knowledge and attitude of these men regarding HIV/AIDS were in a deplorable state. Most of them had multiple sex partners and they never used condoms in the last one month. In another study conducted among MSM in four cities - Bangalore, Hyderabad, Puducherry and Sylhet, in 2000, nearly 78% to 96% of MSM were found to have multiple partners in the last one month. In the same study condom use was slightly higher (29% to 45%) than the current study (22.2%). What was even more disturbing was that many of these men were married and served as the bridge population in the transmission of different sexually transmitted diseases including the HIV epidemic. It was quiet distressing to find that 25% of these MSM were students-who were young people who had a productive life and career to fulfill. Getting exposed to HIV/AIDS thus meant a great loss of the most productive population of the country. So from the above study, we conclude, that time has come to address the needs of this highly vulnerable group. The researchers cleared the misconceptions and counseled each member of the study population after the interview was completed. They were also taught the correct way of using condom taking help of clay models at the end of the study. However, extensive, effective and energizing IEC with the involvement of motivated peer group to improve the knowledge, attitude and sexual practices of this high risk group is the need of the hour.
| Acknowledgement|| |
We extend our sincere thanks to all the study participants and health workers of the clinic for cooperating with us during the study period.
| References|| |
|1.||UNAIDS 2008 Report of the global AIDS epidemic. Available from: http://www.unaids.org/en/KnowledgeCentre/HIVData/GlobalReport/2008/2008_Global_report.asp. [last accessed on 2008 Dec 26]. |
|2.||National AIDS Control Organization, HIV/AIDS epidemiological Surveillance and Estimation report for the year 2005. Available from: http://www.nacoonline.org/Quick_Links/HIV_Data. [last accessed on 2008 Dec 26]. |
|3.||Bryan AD, Fisher JD, Benziger TJ. HIV Prevention Information, Motivation, Behavioural Skills and Behaviour among Truck Drivers in Chennai, India. AIDS 2000;41:756-8. |
|4.||Pappas G, Khan O, Wright J, Khan S, Kumaramagalam L, O′Neill J. Males who have sex with males (MSM) and HIV/AIDS in India: The Hidden Epidemic. AIDS and Public Policy Journal 2001;16:4-17. |
|5.||Chakrapani, Venkatesan, Babu P, Ebenezer T. Hijras in sex work face discrimination in the Indian health-care system. Research for Sex Work 2004;7:12-4. |
|6.||Khan S. MSM and HIV/AIDS in India. Naz Foundation International. 2004. Available at url.http://www.nfi.net/NFI%20Publications/Essays/2004/MSM,%20HIV%20and%20India.pdf. [last accessed on 2008 Dec 26]. |
[Table 1], [Table 2], [Table 3], [Table 4], [Table 5]
|This article has been cited by|
||Sex in the city: Privacy-making practices, spatialized intimacies and the environmental risks of men-who-have-sex-with-men in South India
| ||Robert Lorway, Sandra D.H. Hwang, Sushena Reza-Paul, Akram Pasha, Syed Hafeez Ur Rahman, Stephen Moses, James Blanchard |
| ||Health & Place. 2011; |
|[VIEW] | [DOI]|
||HIV in Indian MSM: Reasons for a concentrated epidemic & strategies for prevention
| || Thomas, B., Mimiaga, M.J., Kumar, S., Swaminathan, S., Safren, S.A., Mayer, K.H. |
| ||Indian Journal of Medical Research. 2011; 134(12): 920-929 |