|Year : 2011 | Volume
| Issue : 1 | Page : 31-35
Study of sexual behaviour of bar-girls residing in an urban slum area of Mumbai
Abhay Nirgude1, Mridula J Solanki2, Ratnendra R Shinde2, Poonam Naik1
1 Department of Community Medicine, Kamineni Institute of Medical Sciences, Sreepuram, Narketpally, India
2 Department of Preventive and Social Medicine, Seth G.S.Medical College, Parel, Mumbai, India
|Date of Submission||18-Dec-2009|
|Date of Acceptance||08-Feb-2010|
|Date of Web Publication||12-May-2011|
317, Wardens Quarters KIMS Campus Sreepuram, Narketpally, District Nalgonda, Narketpally
Source of Support: None, Conflict of Interest: None
| Abstract|| |
Background: Bar girls are unorganized, difficult to reach high-risk group, and an urban phenomenon. Objectives: To study the demographic profile and sexual behavior of bar girls. Materials and Methods: Study setting is an urban slum area situated in the northwest part of Mumbai. Study design is a community-based cross-sectional study. Study duration was from January 2003 to January 2005. Phase I: Identification of key informants was done. Phase II: Mapping of bar girls in the study area was done with the help of key informants. Sampling: Out of the estimated 800-1200 bar girls, 120 bar girls who were willing to participate in the study were included in the study after obtaining informed consent. Confidentiality of names and locations was assured to both key informants and study subjects. Information was gathered about demographic profile, educational status, and their sexual behavior by conducting one to one interview with the use of predesigned, pre-tested semi-structured questionnaire. Results: Most of the bar girls were in the age group of 21-25 years 52 (43.3%). None of them were educated above secondary level. Most of the subjects belong to West Bengal state 58 (48.4%). Majority of the subjects 88 (73.3%) reported that they have ever practiced commercial sex, and money was the criteria of selection of customers 53 (60.22%). Condom usage was reported less with regular customer as compared with that of nonregular customers (χ2 = 6.02, P < 0.02). Conclusions: Need to emphasize condom use with each and every sexual act irrespective of type of customers.
Keywords: Bar girls, condom use, sexual behavior
|How to cite this article:|
Nirgude A, Solanki MJ, Shinde RR, Naik P. Study of sexual behaviour of bar-girls residing in an urban slum area of Mumbai. Indian J Community Med 2011;36:31-5
|How to cite this URL:|
Nirgude A, Solanki MJ, Shinde RR, Naik P. Study of sexual behaviour of bar-girls residing in an urban slum area of Mumbai. Indian J Community Med [serial online] 2011 [cited 2020 Feb 20];36:31-5. Available from: http://www.ijcm.org.in/text.asp?2011/36/1/31/80790
| Introduction|| |
The "bar girl" is an urban phenomenon and has not been studied much in India. Sex workers can be categorized into 6 main typologies, based on where they work and more specifically on where they recruit or solicit clients and not where they live or actually entertain the clients. Bar girls has been categorized as "Other Sex Workers," whose primary occupational identity may vary, but a large proportion of their occupation group, but not all, often engages in commercial sex regularly and in significant volumes.  Bar girls has also been categorized as Indirect Primary Female Sex workers (FSWs), which means FSWs who have other sources of income and primarily solicit clients at their place of work, which are venues where facilitating sex work is their main purpose (eg, massage parlors, bar-based sex workers, singing and dancing girls). , Bar girls are also categorized as female sex workers non-brothel based (FSWs-nbb).They are not entirely dependent on prostitution. They may or may not resort to prostitution. Unlike female sex workers, which are brothel-based (FSWs-bb), they have some degree of freedom in terms of practicing prostitution. 
Behavioral surveillance survey in Maharashtra by Family Health International (FHI) reported that non-brothel-based FSWs were vulnerable because they were less likely to be reached by interventions, and they had less access to condoms or STI treatment.  Also there is shift of male clients away from the brothel-based sex industry into more informal non-brothel-based sex exchange, this is cause of concern. For the purpose of HIV/AIDS intervention, a program need to take into account that FSWs working in different settings have different levels of vulnerability and risk for contracting sexually transmitted infections.  The present study was an attempt to reach out to the difficult to reach the core high-risk group and assess their demographic profile and sexual behavior.
| Materials and Methods|| |
The study was conducted in an urban slum situated in the northwest part of Mumbai. The slum is under the jurisdiction of P/North BMC ward of Mumbai. It is adopted by a teaching institute and hospital of Mumbai. The population of the study area is 1,50,000.
January 2003 to January 2005.
Community-based cross-sectional study.
To map the bar girls in the study area, the study process was divided into 2 phases.
In this phase identification of key informants, such as females taking care of children of bar girls, commercial sex workers availing health care facilities from urban health center, and NGOs working for children of sex workers, was done. To overcome the fear among key informants, it was needed to explain to them repeatedly, the objectives of this study. They were assured that confidentiality will be maintained.
During II phase
Information was gathered from key informants about the location and approximate numbers of bar girls. It was found that the approximate numbers of bar girls residing in the study area were 800-1200 and these bar girls frequently change their residence.
A pilot study was carried out, by using partially structured questionnaire. The purpose of which is to test the feasibility of the study and to finalize the study questionnaire. It was found that many of the bar girls refuse to participate in study, that is, only 23 out of 95 bar girls agreed to participate in the study. Of those who participated in the study, majority were reluctant to talk on issues related to sexual behaviors. Finally, only 10 bar girls gave consent and participated in the pilot study. The response rate to pilot study questionnaire was only 10.5% (10/95). The data collected during the pilot study was evaluated and the questionnaire was modified.
Considering the poor response rate during the pilot study and difficulty in reaching out to them it was decided to take 10% representative sample of the estimated study population (800-1200).
Many of the bar girls were not willing to participate in the study. It was only after repeated assurances regarding confidentiality from the key informants, social workers, and authors some of them had given informed consent. A mapping exercise was undertaken in two phases across all study area to gather information about of study population, which found to be 800-1200 in number. In view of poor response during pilot study and difficult to reach out group, it was decided to take 10% representative sample of the estimated study population by convenient sampling method. Accordingly, when a sample of 120 was achieved, the data collection was stopped.
Before starting the interview, informal meetings with bar girls along with some key informants known to them were carried out to develop rapport with them. Each respondent was explained in brief about the need and purpose of the study. Confidentiality of their names and location was assured at the meeting. Possible benefits to them were explained. Data were collected by one-to-one interview technique by using pre-tested, predesigned, semi-structured questionnaire. Information was gathered regarding demographic profile, educational status, and sexual behavior of the bar girls. Data were compiled, analyzed, and presented in percentages and proportions. Chi-square test was used to test the significance of association.
| Results|| |
The mean age of the study sample was 21.5 years. The age of bar girls ranged between 16 and 37 years. Majority of the bar girls, that is, 43.3% were found to be in the age group of 21-25 years [Table 1]. None of the bar girls was having education above the secondary level. A significant number, that is, 39/120 (32.5%) of bar girls were illiterate [Table 2]. Lack of education was one of the reasons for their not being able to find any other alternative occupation. Most of the bar girls, that is, 48.4% (58/120) were hailing from West Bengal, followed by Uttar Pradesh 16/120 (13.3%) and only 9.2%, that is, 11/120 bar girls were from Maharashtra [Table 3]. Maximum, that is, 73.3% (88/120) bar girls had accepted that they practiced commercial sex. Money was reported as the most common criterion for selection of customer by 60.22% (53/88) bar girls, 23.86% said that they go with customer whom they like and who are affectionate. VIP (10.22%) includes those customers who are very important for the bar owner [Table 4]. Although all, who were involved in the commercial sex were using condom, the frequency of its use varied considerably, that is, 46.60% (41/88) were using condom at every commercial sexual act (always), and 53.4% (47/88) were using condom during most of the times (often) [Table 5]. Chi-square test shows significant association between the type of customer and condom use during their last commercial sexual act (χ2 = 6.02, df = 1, P < 0.02). Condom use was less with regular customers as compared with that of nonregular customers [Table 6]. Majority of bar girls, that is, 84/88 (95.4%) were of the opinion that condom use prevents them from acquiring HIV/AIDS. A significant number of bar girls, that is, 14/88 (15.9%) were of the opinion that HIV/AIDS could not be prevented by continuing in this occupation and 17/88 (19.3%) bar girls said that they indulge in commercial sex with only selected customers to protect themselves from HIV/AIDS [Table 7].
|Table 2: Distribution of participants according to their educational status (n=120)|
Click here to view
|Table 4: Distribution of participants as per their selection criteria of customer for commercial sex (n=88)|
Click here to view
|Table 6: Association between the type of customer during last commercial sexual act and use of condom (n=88/120)|
Click here to view
|Table 7: Distribution of participants as per preventive measures practiced against HIV/AIDS (n=88/120)|
Click here to view
| Discussion|| |
Young girls are preferred in dancing bars as majority of study subjects were less than 25 years (67.5%) with mean age of 21.5 years. VEDH, in their study among bar girls of Navi-Mumbai observed that 75% of the bar girls were younger than 25 years.  A study done by Ishindo et al among bar girls of Malawi's major cities reported 19 years as the average age of study population.  The present study reports that 37.5% of the respondents were currently married. Although 38.3% were unmarried, 19.56% of them were having children and 39.13% had a history of abortion. This shows the need to address the unmet needs of the study population regarding family planning. Ishindo et al found that 10.2% subjects have married at one time or another and 11.9% having living children.  VEDH reported that 64% of bar girls were married.  In the study done by Riedner et al, among female bar workers in Mbeya Region of Tanzania observed that 21% (127/600) subjects were married or living with partner.  Dandona et al, in their study on demography and sex work characteristics of FSWs in India, reported that 40.6% were currently married and 30.7% were separated/divorced.  Our study found that 32.5% were illiterate. When educational status was compared with their involvement in commercial sex, it was found that they indulged in commercial sex irrespective of their educational status (P > 0.05). Data from Behavioral Surveillance Survey (BSS) in Maharashtra 2001 by FHI shows that 45% female sex workers, non-brothel based (FSWs-nbb) were illiterate.  Dandona et al, in their study among non-brothel-based female sex workers observed that 74.7% subjects were not even enrolled in the school.  As per the information of International Labour Organization on human trafficking in Asia, in India trafficking in large numbers take place from the poorer states to the large cities, such as Kolkata, Delhi, and Mumbai.  The present study shows that most of the subjects hailed from West Bengal (48.4%), Uttar Pradesh (13.3%), and Rajasthan (12.5%).
Bar girls working in different types of bars do not start and end with sex always. They normally start with dancing, and in some type of bar they give companionship to the customer for drinking. But sometimes they end up giving sexual favors. Our study majority, that is, 88/120 (73.3%) of respondents accepted that they did practice commercial sex. In the study conducted by SERO, with technical assistance form Family Health International during 1999-2001, reported that: number of women involved in sex activities at lodges/bars/hotels were estimated as 6000 among 1141 units mapped in Mumbai and Navi-Mumbai. It was also found that sexual activity took place in 41.6% of mapped units. It was also observed that these places act as both access and action venues, that is, places where commercial sex could be both negotiated (solicited) and performed.  Most of the subjects reported that money (60.22%) is the criterion for selection of a customer for commercial sex in our study. Ishindo et al found that 92.8% subjects had given earning money as reason to work as a bar girl.  In order to resolve the issues of financial hardship there is need to address the issues, such as empowerment of bar girls and measures to provide more economic options. These observations drawn from the study will act as data for advocacy to convince policy makers and community leaders of the importance of an empowered approach in targeted interventions among bar girls. In our study, everyone who practiced commercial sex was using condoms, but the frequency of condom use varied considerably with the type of customer, 46.60% of bar girls were using condom during each commercial sexual act, and 53.40% were using it most of the time. A significant association was seen between condom use and type of customer entertained during last commercial sex (P < 0.02). It was found that condom was used less with regular customer (69.8%) as compared with nonregular customer (91.4%). National Behavioural Surveillance Survey 2001 and 2006 also observed variation in condom usage with the type of client and FSWs. Proportion of FWSs-nbb reporting the use of condom has gone up from 68.9% in 2001 to 85% in 2006 in case of nonpaying clients and from 34.3% in 2001 to 39% in 2006 in case of paying clients.  Also the proportion of FSWs-nbb using condom was considerably lower as compared with FSWs-bb.  This shows that FSWs-nbb and their clients are more vulnerable when it comes to condom use. These regular partners form a transmission bridge from bar girls to the general populations. HRG members or HRGs have many sexual partnerships with different bridge population members, who in turn have at least one partner in general population.  HIV transmission dynamics in India are such that unless effective targeted HIV prevention saturates the most at-risk HRGs of FSWs, the epidemic will not be controlled.  Ishindo et al observed that only 23.3% subjects reported to have ever used condoms during commercial sex.  Dandona et al in their study among non-brothel-based female sex workers in India observed that 23.9% subjects reported that they had never used condom. It was also found that 94% FSWs had not used condom for the last penetrative sex with their regular sex partner.  Similarly, a study done by Ramakrishna et al and Ramesh et al reported a lower use of condom with regular clients, which is 26.6% and 31.9%, respectively. , Kapiga et al, in their study among female bar and hotel workers in Northern Tanzania observed that HIV seroprevalence was seen more (34.1%) in occasional condom users and less (17.5%) in those who use condom consistently.  Majority of the respondents, that is, 95.4% were using condom as one of the preventive measure against HIV/AIDS. Practicing commercial sex with only selected clients was reported as one of the preventive measure by 19.3% subjects. Significant percentages of subjects (15.9%) were of the opinion that HIV/AIDS could not be prevented by continuing in this occupation. In the study done by SERO and Blackstone Market facts with technical assistance form FHI on communication need assessment, they stated that, some of the non-brothel-based sex workers were fatalistic and believe that their lives were going nowhere and HIV/AIDS was inevitable. 
| Conclusions|| |
This study will help to standardize the approach to scale up coverage among bar girls.. Young age, lack of proper education, unmet needs of family planning, uncertainty about future prospects of their children? Also difficulty in accessibility and stigma and discrimination associated with their occupation are found to be challenges before public health experts for organizing preventive interventions among bar girls. High-risk sexual behavior of bar girls with their regular clients and incorrect perception about HIV/AIDS prevention is putting them and their clients at a higher risk of acquiring HIV/AIDS.
There is a need to address barriers to condom usage with regular partners and special efforts should be made to improve condom negotiation and decision-making skills in sexual encounters. Also it is essential to work with clients, partners of bar girls, to create awareness about the importance of using condom for every penetrative sexual act irrespective of the type of sexual partner.
It is needed to undertake special efforts by identifying and involving key informants in reaching out to these bar girls and organize preventive interventions along with rehabilitation by providing them meaningful employment. These bar girls enrolled in the study can be motivated and recruited as peer educators for the HRG community, especially the FSWs-nbb.
| Acknowledgment|| |
The authors would like to acknowledge the co-operation extended by the key informants in identifying and gaining confidence of study subjects. Names of these informants could not be mentioned as confidentiality was assured.
| References|| |
|1.||National AIDS Control Organization (NACO). Targeted Interventions under NACP III. Vol. 1. Core High Risk Groups. Report. NACO, New Delhi: 2007a. |
|2.||Buzdugan R, Halli SS, Cowan FM. The female sex work typology in India in the contest of HIV/AIDS. Trop Med Int Health 2009;14:673-87. |
|3.||ORG Centre for Social research with technical assistance from Family Health International, 1999-2001, funded by USAID. Preparatory studies titled, "Behavioural Surveillance Survey in Maharashtra", Page no 1-37. Available from: http://www.avertsociety.org/Bssavertprepstudyindia.pdf. |
|4.||Research abstracts on social defence and trafficking prevention 1998-2009.Documentation centre for women and children. National Institute of public co-operation and child development, New Delhi 2010. Needs assessment of Bar-girls in Navi-Mumbai for planning appropriate interventions to ameliorate their current conditions by VEDH 2001. Available from: http://www.nipccd.in/reports/rasd.pdf. |
|5.||Ishindo PL. Sexual behaviours in the face of risk: The cause of bar girls in Malawi′s major cities. Health Trans Rev 1995;5:153-60. |
|6.||Riedner G, Rusizoka M, Hoftmann O, Nichombev F, Lyamuya E, Mmbando D, et al. Baseline survey of sexually transmitted infections in a cohort of female bar workers in Mbeya Region, Tanzania. Sex Transm Infect 2003;79:382-7. |
|7.||Dandona R, Dandona L, Kumar GA, Gutierrez JP, McPherson S, Samuels F, et al. Demography and sex work characteristics of female sex workers in India. BMC Int Health Hum Rights 2006;6:5. |
|8.||Dandona R, Dandona L, Gutierrez JP, Kumar AG, McPherson S, Samuels F, et al. High risk of HIV in Non-brothel based female sex workers in India. BMC Public Health 2005;5:87. |
|9.||International Labour Organization: Demand side of human trafficking in Asia: Empirical findings. Regional project on combating child trafficking for labour and sexual exploitation (TICSA-II) 2006. Available from: http://www.humantrafficking.org/uploads/publications/ilo06_demand_side_of_human_tiaef.pdf.International. |
|10.||SERD, Blackstone Market Facts with technical assistance from Family Health International, 1999-2001, preparatory studies, titled ′Mapping of commercial sex access points and relevant service outlets in Maharashtra′. Available from: http://www.fhi.org/NR......./Mappavertprepstudyindiaenhv.pdf. |
|11.||National AIDS Control Organization [Home Page] National Behavioural Surveillance Survey (BSS) 2006.Female Sex Workers (FWSs) and their clients. Available from: http://www.nacoonline.org/upload/NACO%20PDF/Female_Sex_Workers_(FSWs)_and_Their_Clients.pdf. |
|12.||Ramkrishnan L, Gautam A, Goswami P, Kallam S, Adhikary R, Mainkar MK, et al. Programme coverage, condom use and STI treatment among FSWs in a large scale HIV prevention programme: Results from cross-sectional surveys in 22 districts in southern India. Sex Transm Infect 2010;86:662-8. |
|13.||Ramesh BM, Beattie TS, Shajy I, Washington R, Jagannathan L, Reza-Paul S, et al. Changes in risk behaviours and prevalence of sexually transmitted infections following HIV preventive interventions among female sex workers in five districts in Karnataka state, South India. Sex Transm Infect 2010;86:117-24. |
|14.||Kapiga SH, Sam NE, Shao JF, Renjifo B, Masenga EJ, Kiwelu IE, et al. HIV-1 Epidemic Among Female Bar and Hotel Workers In Northern Tanzania: Risk factors and opportunities for prevention for prevention. J Acquir Immune Defic Syndr 2002;29:409-17. |
|15.||SERD, Blackstone Market Facts with technical assistance from Family Health International, 1999-2001, preparatory studies, titled ′Communication Needs Assessment in Maharashtra′. Available from: http://www.avertsociety.org/CNAavertprepstudyindia.pdf. |
[Table 1], [Table 2], [Table 3], [Table 4], [Table 5], [Table 6], [Table 7]